Radio Stuff. Still posting comments about Country music but Music 1's taken over my working life now. As time allows, I'll be posting thoughts and ideas from my archives

Music Scheduling Software Fails

What’s Wrong With Music Scheduling Software?
Consider this:

At the end of the 70’s, radio’s top program directors had developed rotation systems that ensured songs in each category got equal play; that Currents didn’t schedule in the same quarter-hour day after day; that all Oldies got play in all the dayparts, that ‘this’ type of song didn’t play next to ‘that’ type of song. It worked well and required about an hour a week to update. (You can read how the RKO stations did it on the Music 1 website under the Documents link.)

As we entered the 80’s, the first software designed to automate the task was introduced. Pitched as a tool that would deliver perfect song rotations with only about ten minutes daily editing time, it did neither. In practice, music scheduling software took a relatively simple craft and made it exceptionally complex. To do the job with software required much more labor, about ten hours a week. Multiple surveys published in Radio and Records during the next two decades reported radio’s music directors continued to spend an average ninety minutes a day with the software; a quarter of the work-week to do what had previously taken an hour. Music directors had become slaves to an algorithm.

It’s a bit better today. Average daily playlist editing time is down to about an hour. This isn’t necessarily because the software has improved so much as because staff cuts and triple-duty employees don’t have the time to do proper editing. Unless the music director is very careful there are two common fails that often go unnoticed.

The most common music scheduling mistakes are erratic spin counts and inconsistent daypart rotation. The Power Golds were supposed to get 45 plays a month, yet some of them got over 50 spins while others are in the 30’s. Recurrents are supposed to be scheduled in all dayparts, yet some of them bunch up in midday and others get played primarily in afternoons and evenings.

Consistent Spins and Daypart Placement – Why They Matter
What would happen if an advertiser ordered 45 spots a week and you discovered only 37 ads got on the air? And what if you found that the spot had been scheduled only nine times in morning drive instead of the fifteen ordered? The manager, sales manager, account exec and traffic director would all be looking into the traffic/billing software to figure out it out and fix it.

We can all agree that the music we play and how we play it are supremely important factors in our success, yet erratic music schedules don’t get that kind of attention. Why not?

First, money is not directly involved. Second, heritage music schedulers are inherently complex. Any scheduling problem that can be solved with an algorithm (format rule) has a 50/50 chance of creating another problem that requires yet another fix. It is near impossible to get music schedules that are as consistent and as elegant as were those engineered by men like Rick Sklar and Paul Drew four decades ago.

Present Day Thinking
I recently spoke with a music director who spends about 90 minutes editing each day’s log. Why so much time? “Because some of my Medium Currents get scheduled in the same hour too many times and some Power Golds get bunched-up in one or two dayparts. I gotta move a lot of stuff around.”

A call came from a veteran PD. He had read that Music 1 delivers consistent spins for every song in each category. That’s a fact, I told him. “I just don’t see how that is possible”, he said. He’s used his scheduler for twenty years and “some songs are just going to get fewer spins because formatting rules get in the way. To get 35 spins a week on every song in my B-Category, I would have to turn off some important rules.”

That’s life as most music directors know it. They either accept irregular spins and erratic song placement as an unfortunate fact of life, or they must labor long to edit each day’s schedule, fixing flow and rotation problems.

Why Is This Important?
Because radio is a reach-and-frequency medium. We preach that truth every day. We interview our advertiser to discover his objectives, then we sell him the number of spots required to reach the most ears the optimum number of times to meet the goals.

It is reasonable that our music, the content that delivers those listeners to the advertiser, should be scheduled just as carefully as the commercials are. If the Heavy’s are planned for 45 spins a week, then each song in Heavy should get 45 plays. If Power Golds are supposed to get played equally in all dayparts, that should happen.

How Bad Is It? Here’s A Quick Way To See
Print two report types for each of your categories. First, print a weekly spins for Currents and Recurrents. Print a monthly report for everything else.

Next, print a rotation history chart for five songs from within each category. See where the songs have scheduled, observe hour and daypart placement.

If you don’t like what you see, clear out all of the secondary rules then schedule two weeks and check again. Keep at it until it is better. If that can’t be done, consider changing schedulers.

Music 1, PlayoutONE and Classic Rock

From One Of Our Music 1 Users: Hey Steve … just thought I’d drop you a line and tell you that I took your advice and checked out PlayoutOne – loved it – and purchased it. It is great to be able to use Music 1 with it for the scheduling. I am broadcasting aContinue Reading

Slacker Gets Disc Jockeys

Today’s (6.24.16) news brief from the RAIN newsletter has an article about what’s called “the discovery wars”. That’s the competition between Spotify, Slacker, SoundCloud, Pandora, as they try to hook more listening. The biggest draw for listening is new music. Quoting Edison research, over 50% of the population is interested in “keeping up to date”Continue Reading

Music 1 – The Most Efficient Tool In The Box

Being the old radio vet that I am, I still remember those articles that would appear about every 18 months or so in Radio & Records Magazine. One of the format columnists would do a survey with their reporting stations with questions about their choice and use of music scheduling software. The stand-out question forContinue Reading

Radio: What’s Missing

A couple of years ago, I read an article by Sean Ross and teed-off on it. I don’t remember if I ever even sent it to him. Today I came across the rather long ramble that I’d put to paper back then. Skimmed through it and decided to share it here. ———- 11.27.14 I readContinue Reading

Playing Movie Music

Back when I was an itty bitty baby DJ, I lucked into working for one of the great programming minds of the time. One of his tricks was to check the movie show times for any film featuring a hit song. When “Goldfinger” finally got to our town in the early spring of ’65, heContinue Reading

The Best Time To Be A Media Entrepreneur

I got this link off James Cridland’s blog. I was lucky enough to get into my career when I was 16. If I was that kid today, I’d print this guy’s list and pin it to my bedroom wall. And probably tape it inside my high school locker, too. I wanted to be IN it.Continue Reading

Blue Ain’t Your Color – Keith Urban (Capitol)

Good gawd, this is a brilliant record. A classic it will be. Everything about this one is perfect. Fabulous on so many levels. Essentially, it’s a pick-up song. A guy talking up a gal in a bar. But it transcends the genre. The arrangement pays homage with it’s hints of influence. When was the lastContinue Reading

Sierra – Maddie & Tae (Dot)

I live for records that hit me like this one does. You hit the play button and it gives you some joy. It’s the kind of record that screams: Put me on the radio right now, share me with people. Now I love hooks, you know. Real hooks, not the kind of pseudo-hooks I hearContinue Reading

Lights Come On – Jason Aldean (Broken Bow)

Sorry, but it’s little more than an exercise in self-indulgence. Another song about partying. Ahem, concert-attending. Ain’t it great? Well, yes it is. If you’re half-drunk. Maybe if you’re high, although I haven’t heard much from the boy that would fit a weed groove. If, on the other hand, you are in the car andContinue Reading